E&J's POV

 Textbook Evaluation Essay 

Group 19

Elizette Ysais and Jessica Zepeda

Word Count: 1746

Artworks from all around the world can be perceived differently by each art historian. Their own experiences can have an influence on the way they comprehend the artwork. The textbook, Art: A Brief History by Marilyn Stokstad and Michael Cothren, helps students understand not only the content, but also the background context and history of the artwork. Both Stokstad and Cothren aim to educate their readers on the different varieties of art around the world. The book goes in depth on each work of art, while trying not to have a biased point of view. Art: A Brief History, achieves its aims by going in depth on the content, context, and all of the aspects of the artworks historical background in order to give unbiased information. Although there was no clear bias shown in the text, the author did subconsciously show more of a “gravitational pull” towards the western arts than the non-western arts. By the way the author writes about both arts and even by their word choices while explaining the different types of art, the authors subtly reveal the way that the western arts are influencing the book more than the non-western arts do overall. By picking apart the language, details, and words used in this textbook, we are able to analyze how the authors approach both types of arts and compare them to find the differences and similarities between the two. 

        The author writes about the sculpture David by Donatello (Figure 1) in a very positive way—explaining how the sculpture was a subject that invoked heroism. The author writes about the Nkisi Nkonde power figure (Figure 2) as it being a dramatic example of how Africans transform their art of their usage. The description of the Nkisi Nkonde as dramatic shows how the author of the book interprets African artwork as being on the extreme side. On the other hand, the sculpture of David is interpreted by the author as a revolutionary sculpture that was met with much praise and dignity behind it. Although the sculpture was shown in the nude and depicting a scene that was after the killing of the giant Goliath, the sculpture is not recognized as a symbol of death nor is met with any negative connotation. David by Donatello is described as having a dreamy expression and also having long piqued art-historical interest. With the language the author uses to discuss this artwork, it makes it clear how much that sculpture was positively accepted and recognized. The description of the Nkisi Nkonde as a visual document of the history of the conflicts and afflictions that have threatened the Kongo community makes the artwork seem as a negative symbol for African culture. The way the author emphasizes the conflict and the function of the Nkisi Nkonde as a divinatory and judicial function to seek out wrongdoers, this brings about the harsh and scary attributes associated with the use of the power figure and of the Kongo people. Although the Nkisi Nkonde was a symbol of power and an arbiter of justice for the Kongo people, the way the author writes about the artwork puts more emphasis on the “scariness” of its function rather than explaining it in a more positive and non-dramatic way.

                                                      

                  David by Dontatello                                      Nkisi Nkonde (Power Figure)

                           (Figure 1)                                                              (Figure 2)

Art Detective by Elizette Ysais

In my house, we have a picture of what it seems like the interior of a Gothic Cathedral. I had assumed it was from a Gothic Cathedral because one of my family members took this picture when they went to France and it has similar characteristics of these types of cathedrals. The image is showing clerestory windows, which are the topmost zone of a wall with windows in a basilica that provides light into the central interior space (nave), and rose windows, which are round windows that are often filled with stained glass, set into tracery patterns in the form of wheel spokes (Stokstad and Cothren 594,597). Both of these types of windows are characteristic and common to be seen in Gothic Cathedrals. When the light from outside goes through the stained glass off the windows, it creates an almost angelic look which adds to the feeling of a peaceful church. In Gothic Cathedrals, the aspect of light was very important for them because it created a specific mood for the inside. The light radiating through the colorful stained glass, makes the cathedral seem heavenly and divine. Many people from all over the world travel to these gothic cathedrals to experience the beauty of these serene churches.

Art Detective by Jessica Zepeda

This cross was made in and brought from a city known as Tonala from Jalisco, Mexico. It was blessed in the cathedral of Guadalajara. It is a wood cross which had each part carved individually and then put together. The cross shows Jesus Christ nailed to it with the letters INRI on top of his head. The letters are initials for the Latin title “Iesvs Nazarenvs Rex Ivdaeorvm”—meaning in English, “Jesus of Nazareth, the King of the Jews.” Latin was the official language of the Roman Empire at the time and during a crucifixion, it was common for Rome to write the crime over a man’s head for which he was dying for. Jesus’ crime was that because he declared himself to be God—this is the basis for Christianity. Crucifixion was carried out in Christian tradition by nailing the limbs to the wood of the cross. This method of punishment had come to serve the Roman people as an emblem of triumph over sin and death. Jesus Christ was looking down to the right because he was seeing his mother and all the people who whipped him and acclaimed “forgive them father because they don’t know what they’re doing.” The detail shown of his upper body (his ribs accentuated) made it seem that Jesus was hungry or thirsty. This is because Jesus asks for water while on the cross and they gave him vinegar with a sponge. This cross is a common and powerful symbol for Christians and is widely recognized as both a sign of Christ himself and of the faith of Christians.

         If we were the authors of Art: A Brief History, we would go more in depth and include more arts of the non-western areas. In this textbook, Stokstad and Cothren briefly touch on the subjects of art in non-western areas, for example the art of Africa. The chapter on African art is much shorter compared to the other chapters on western art and even ancient Egyptian art. Egypt, being a country in Africa, gets a much larger chapter on the artwork from their time. The art of the Americas chapter also does not get much attention. The authors touch on these chapters very briefly and put an emphasis on how some of the artwork from Africa and the Americas inflicted fear on the travelers from Europe. If we were the authors we would try to be more equal when discussing western and non-western arts. We think it should be 50/50 on the amount of information they include and also be more unbiased when writing about the different styles. However, we would exclude the heavy Eurocentric language Stokstad and Cothren include in the textbook. When speaking about non-western art, we believe that it should not be constantly compared to Eurocentric standards. The authors in the textbook praise art from the west but do not have the same attitudes towards the “other” non-western art and cultures. They do discuss what it means for art to be “primitive” since it was once used by Western art historians to combine the art of Africa, the Pacific Islands, and the indigenous art of the Americas. The term was rooted off of racism and colonialism from the west and therefore it was meant to imply that these cultures and civilizations were not sophisticated enough (Stokstad and Cothren, 434). With us as the authors of Art: A Brief History, we would make sure that both western and non-western artworks and cultures get treated with an equal, unbiased point of view.

        Overall, the textbook provides clear information on all aspects of the artworks being discussed. They do a very good job on going over the content and historical information that is needed to fully understand the work of art. The authors also do a good job on choosing the artworks that are discussed in the text. All of the artworks are proven to be of great significance and are followed with adequate information supporting that. However, they do not do a very good job at making sure both western and non-western art are talked about equally. If the western and non-western arts were to have equal amounts of pages dedicated to each, the textbook would have been larger to accommodate both types of art. By including equal pages for both western and non-western arts, the textbook would have been relatively large--maybe too large for some publishers' liking. That could be the reason why the authors did not talk about both arts equally, but they could have tried to cut down on the western arts a little more so they could have included more information on the non-western areas. The non-western arts occupy a larger area of the world and cover many more cultures and religions than the western arts do. It would even make sense for the non-western arts to have occupied more of the textbook than the western arts because of the greater amount of art that should and needs to be covered from the non-western arts of the world. 

        The textbook Art: A Brief History, written by Marilyn Stokstad and Michael Cothren, does a great job at explaining the content, background context, and history of artworks. However, the stigmas of praising the western artwork and using heavy Eurocentric language creates an unbalance when discussing western and non-western art. This stigma towards these “primitive” civilizations and artworks have been embedded into society since colonialism began. Being rooted in racism from colonialism times, art historians have the chance to shift the way non-western art is perceived. All artworks, cultures, and civilizations should be addressed equally and should not have to be compared to the heavily praised western art like many art historians do. 




 

Comments

  1. It is interesting how you described the authors siding to a more favored view rather than them being biased. Love the layout! Great job. -Mireya Arana

    ReplyDelete
  2. I liked how you said the textbook had a "gravitational pull" towards the West. thesis statement was well written and to the point, the essay overall was well organized.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I agree with your concluding statement that there is a great unbalance when comparing the western art and non-western art in the textbook, good blog post!

    ReplyDelete
  4. I thoroughly enjoyed your blog, the last statement was very agreeable and I enjoyed how much information was written in the art detective section as well. I think you have an explained very well the need for Eastern art to be showcased as such rather than with coined terms that favor the common Westerner's bias.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I really enjoyed reading the art detective part about the Gothic cathedral, it was very interesting. -Nikki Phan

    ReplyDelete
  6. good job mentioning the good things in the book and also the improvements needed. - Janessa Gomez

    ReplyDelete
  7. Loved the blog, really liked how you were critical on the book and what it could have had more of. Great job!

    - Justin Ya

    ReplyDelete
  8. I really enjoyed the simplicity you kept throughout. You cut straight to all the points and I think the only thing you could adjust would be that there were no titles located on your post. - Jade Woodworth

    ReplyDelete
  9. I love your conclusion and how it is clear and precise! It is a great summary of what you guys explained throughout the post. -Julinna Fletes

    ReplyDelete
  10. the way you wrote about the bias was super interesting and fun to read, loved all of the art works chosen from the book

    ReplyDelete
  11. interesting insight on the book's biases, love the different perspective! -gabe de pina

    ReplyDelete
  12. Your take on the textbook's bias was refreshing to see. You guys really took an interesting and new path to your blog.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Your conclusion was great and very specific it was. Also great mention about the role of the textbook, nice. - araceli

    ReplyDelete
  14. It was straight to the point, and had an interesting take on the textbook, very good.

    ReplyDelete
  15. I agree with your argument that the book should’ve been equal with how it described each culture. Clear point and straight to the point! - Valerie Guerrero

    ReplyDelete
  16. very clear points stated. ~ Brennan Garcia

    ReplyDelete
  17. i liked the cross as an example of an art piece because it reminds me that a lot of things that don't seem to be art, can be art.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Nice and simple, straight to the point. Analysis was well done

    ReplyDelete
  19. Good blog post, good comparison of the western and eastern portrayals.
    -Ivan Vargas

    ReplyDelete
  20. I like how you guys mention the good things the book provides in the conclusion. The analysis was great. Nice Job!

    ReplyDelete
  21. Love that pop of color! I like how concise and clear everything is while still providing great detail!
    - Lisset Ochoa

    ReplyDelete
  22. We liked how you put yourself in the authors shoes and described what you would change if you were them. A good point you mentioned was how it was probably cut short due to the publishers not wanting it to be too dense. Really nice analysis and art detective as well
    - group 15 Katerina, Clarissa, and Amber.

    ReplyDelete
  23. I enjoyed the format very appealing!

    ReplyDelete
  24. The paragraph in the beginning of the blog isn't indented. Besides that, I liked how the textbook title/artworks are italicized.

    ReplyDelete
  25. Your pros and cons on the textbook are on point and I think it sums up the book perfectly. The cross is a good detection of Christian imagery.

    ReplyDelete
  26. I enjoyed how you mentioned some corrections you guys would make to help the textbook not have the bias it currently has. - Cristina Molina

    ReplyDelete
  27. You had a really great analysis. It was clear, persuasive, and shows the bias perception of the textbook.

    ReplyDelete
  28. I really like how your groups POV about the author was different to most of the others blog posts. The layout us also very nice because its centered and the pics follow the flow which makes it easier to read along.

    ReplyDelete
  29. I really enjoyed the first art detective because it was so eye catching and interesting. -Stefania Ortiz

    ReplyDelete
  30. The art detective section is very strong in analysis. The analysis of the textbook is very well stated as well.

    ReplyDelete
  31. The conclusion and introduction were great. The art detective were descriptive and provides a good explanation about the history of the image.

    ReplyDelete
  32. Love the layout and how you explained the art pieces that were included!- Violeta Gamboa

    ReplyDelete
  33. Really good analyses in all the different sections, they are very in depth

    ReplyDelete
  34. I really enjoyed how your conclusion really brung everything together.

    ReplyDelete
  35. I really liked the analysis on the unbalanced content of African and European within the textbook! The very art detective was very eye catching and the second had a great analysis.

    ReplyDelete
  36. Great job on the blog! I liked that you talked about the deep flaws of the book and how harmful primitivism is! - anthony michel

    ReplyDelete
  37. Iris Gutierrez: It was interesting to read how you perceived the book and found it to not be written with bias, but were still able to address the lack of equality in representation between Western and non-Western art.

    ReplyDelete
  38. Hi i found your blog super interesting, i didn't know that David is complimented more than Nkisi Nkonde, it will be nice if you provided some quotes so we can see the diction that the authors use, other than that it's cool :)

    ReplyDelete
  39. I like how you said we need to not look at non-Euro art through the lens of Euro's standards

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment